Why consensus can be wrong. Why valuations matter more than narratives.
If I asked you where to invest today…
If I asked where to invest over the next ten years, most investors would probably answer without hesitation:
The United States.
After all, the arguments seem compelling.
The U.S. economy has been more resilient.
The world’s largest AI companies are American.
Corporate earnings continue to grow.
The U.S. stock market keeps reaching new highs.
Meanwhile, Europe often appears to face one challenge after another.
Slower economic growth.
An aging population.
Industrial headwinds.
Higher energy costs.
More regulation.
At first glance, the conclusion seems obvious.
Why invest in a region that appears less attractive?
Yet this question already contains a hidden trap.
Financial markets do not reward the most compelling stories.
They reward the gap between expectations and reality.
A Great Economy Is Not Always a Great Investment
This is probably one of the most common mistakes investors make.
They confuse economic strength with investment potential.
These are not the same thing.
A country can have an outstanding economy…
…and still deliver disappointing stock market returns.
Conversely, a region facing economic challenges can produce excellent long-term investment performance.
Why?
Because investors do not buy economies.
They buy prices.
As Warren Buffett famously said:
« Price is what you pay. Value is what you get. »
An outstanding business—or an outstanding economy—can still become a poor investment if investors are willing to pay almost any price to own it.
Markets Always Look Ahead
This is a concept we’ve explored before in Why Do Markets Rise Despite Inflation?
👉 https://portefeuille-serein.com/pourquoi-marches-montent-malgre-inflation/
Financial markets don’t price today’s economy.
They price tomorrow’s expectations.
When good news is already obvious…
…it is usually already reflected in stock prices.
What truly moves markets are surprises.
Expectations Matter More Than Results
We’ve also explained why a stock can fall despite reporting excellent earnings.
👉 https://portefeuille-serein.com/pourquoi-action-baisse-malgre-bons-resultats/
At first, this seems irrational.
A company announces record profits…
…yet its share price declines.
Why?
Because investors expected even better results.
Markets never compare reality with the past.
They compare reality with expectations.
The exact same principle applies to countries and regions.
Europe doesn’t need to become the world’s strongest economy.
It only needs to perform slightly better than investors currently expect.
The Consensus Trap
Once an investment story becomes obvious…
…it also becomes increasingly difficult to profit from it.
Why?
Because most investors are already positioned.
Good news is fully expected.
Bad news becomes capable of disappointing.
On the other hand, when an entire market is widely ignored, expectations become extremely low.
In that environment, even modest improvements can significantly change investor sentiment.
This is precisely why some of the strongest long-term opportunities emerge where pessimism has already been fully priced in.
Valuations Tell a Different Story
For several years, U.S. equities have traded at significantly higher valuation multiples than European equities.
In simple terms…
Investors are willing to pay considerably more for each dollar of corporate earnings in the United States than for each euro of earnings in Europe.
That does not automatically mean U.S. stocks are overvalued.
It simply means investors already expect more.
The higher expectations become…
…the harder they are to exceed.
Conversely, an unpopular market doesn’t need spectacular growth to surprise investors.
It simply needs reality to be slightly better than expected.
History Shows That Consensus Is Often Wrong
At the end of the 1980s…
Japan seemed unstoppable.
Many believed its economic dominance would last forever.
Valuations reached extraordinary levels.
The following decades told a different story.
Likewise, during the European sovereign debt crisis in 2011–2012, many investors questioned the future of the Eurozone itself.
Yet European equities subsequently enjoyed several years of strong performance.
History never repeats itself exactly.
But it frequently rhymes.
One lesson remains remarkably consistent:
Consensus is wrong far more often than people realize.
Capital Flows Never Stay the Same
Markets constantly evolve.
We’ve recently seen this with investors willingly accepting 4% virtually risk-free returns.
👉 https://portefeuille-serein.com/pourquoi-investisseurs-acceptent-4-pourcent/
For more than a decade, equities were almost the only attractive source of returns.
Today, bonds have become competitive again.
Capital moves.
Valuations adjust.
Investor preferences change.
Markets never stand still.
The Dollar and Gold Tell the Same Story
The same principles apply beyond equities.
We’ve explained why the U.S. dollar continued strengthening, even while many investors expected the opposite.
👉 https://portefeuille-serein.com/pourquoi-dollar-americain-monte/
We’ve also shown why gold can fall despite geopolitical tensions.
👉 https://portefeuille-serein.com/or-baisse-guerre-valeurs-refuges/
The mechanism is always the same.
Markets do not react to events themselves.
They react to surprises relative to expectations.
What Most Investors Watch… and What Really Matters
| Most investors focus on | What actually drives long-term returns |
|---|---|
| Economic growth | Expectations already priced in |
| Past performance | Starting valuations |
| Popular narratives | Positive and negative surprises |
| Famous companies | The price paid to own them |
| Consensus | Deviations from consensus |
So… Are Investors Underestimating Europe?
Maybe.
Maybe not.
And that’s not even the most interesting question.
The better question is this:
Has today’s pessimism already been fully priced into European equities?
If the answer is yes…
Europe doesn’t need to become the world’s best-performing region.
It simply needs to perform better than expected.
That is often where the biggest market surprises begin.
Conclusion
The United States has deservedly outperformed global markets for much of the past fifteen years.
It may continue doing so.
No one knows.
But successful investing has never been about identifying the most admired economy.
It has always been about identifying the gap between expectations and reality.
When everyone is looking in the same direction…
…it may be worth quietly looking somewhere else.
Not because the consensus is necessarily wrong.
But because markets tend to reward those who recognize when expectations have become too optimistic… or too pessimistic.
That may be one of the most valuable lessons any long-term investor can learn.
Frequently Asked Questions
Should investors sell U.S. stocks?
No. This article does not argue against investing in the United States. It simply highlights that future returns depend not only on business quality but also on the expectations already reflected in market prices.
Why are European stocks generally cheaper?
European companies are often expected to deliver slower earnings growth. Lower expectations typically translate into lower valuation multiples. Lower valuations do not guarantee higher returns, but they may provide more room for positive surprises.
Are valuations enough to make investment decisions?
No. Valuations are only one part of the equation. Investors should also consider profitability, balance sheets, interest rates, competitive advantages, and long-term business quality.
Why does consensus matter?
Because markets react to the difference between reality and expectations. The more investors agree on a particular outcome, the harder it becomes for that outcome to positively surprise the market.
Laisser un commentaire